{ "schema_version": 1, "environment": { "generated_at": "2026-07-22T15:23:56+00:00", "php_version": "8.4.23", "php_sapi": "cli", "os": "Linux 4.18.0-553.85.1.el8_10.x86_64", "architecture": "x86_64", "cpu": "AMD EPYC-Rome Processor", "memory": "15.02 GiB host total", "opcache_cli": "0", "memory_limit": "1024M", "extensions": [ "json", "openssl", "zlib", "mbstring", "pdo_sqlite" ], "timezone": "UTC", "clock": "hrtime(true)", "rounds": 7 }, "checksum": 5658699, "studies": { "json-encoding-layout": { "slug": "json-encoding-layout", "iterations_per_sample": 70, "rounds": 7, "winner": "Compact JSON", "slowest": "Pretty JSON", "spread_percent": 26.94, "variants": { "Compact JSON": { "median_ns_per_op": 225359.1, "p25_ns_per_op": 225062.96, "p75_ns_per_op": 232093.97, "ops_per_second": 4437.36, "samples_ns_per_op": [ 225359.1, 223897.07, 224899.09, 225226.84, 228546.96, 235640.99, 238648.79 ], "extra": { "output_bytes": 67457 } }, "Pretty JSON": { "median_ns_per_op": 286060.16, "p25_ns_per_op": 278639.71, "p75_ns_per_op": 289801.03, "ops_per_second": 3495.77, "samples_ns_per_op": [ 278077.01, 286060.16, 277745.39, 279202.4, 302325.83, 287855.67, 291746.39 ], "extra": { "output_bytes": 135058 } } } }, "json-decoding-shape": { "slug": "json-decoding-shape", "iterations_per_sample": 90, "rounds": 7, "winner": "Associative arrays", "slowest": "Objects", "spread_percent": 6.8, "variants": { "Associative arrays": { "median_ns_per_op": 562064.51, "p25_ns_per_op": 544184.27, "p75_ns_per_op": 576986.77, "ops_per_second": 1779.16, "samples_ns_per_op": [ 573123.73, 541697.7, 634369.14, 524264.28, 580849.81, 562064.51, 546670.83 ], "extra": [] }, "Objects": { "median_ns_per_op": 600277.53, "p25_ns_per_op": 584358.46, "p75_ns_per_op": 604448.87, "ops_per_second": 1665.9, "samples_ns_per_op": [ 600277.53, 609928.89, 570830.31, 602806.4, 576520.9, 606091.33, 592196.01 ], "extra": [] } } }, "gzip-compression-levels": { "slug": "gzip-compression-levels", "iterations_per_sample": 45, "rounds": 7, "winner": "Level 1", "slowest": "Level 9", "spread_percent": 554.18, "variants": { "Level 1": { "median_ns_per_op": 380097.22, "p25_ns_per_op": 376600.09, "p75_ns_per_op": 394073.93, "ops_per_second": 2630.91, "samples_ns_per_op": [ 402154, 548618.29, 379149.42, 380097.22, 374050.76, 373648.2, 385993.87 ], "extra": { "output_bytes": 9532 } }, "Level 6": { "median_ns_per_op": 927816.67, "p25_ns_per_op": 914775.28, "p75_ns_per_op": 933675.01, "ops_per_second": 1077.8, "samples_ns_per_op": [ 962830.24, 918766.78, 930970.82, 936379.2, 906446.73, 910783.78, 927816.67 ], "extra": { "output_bytes": 6784 } }, "Level 9": { "median_ns_per_op": 2486535.93, "p25_ns_per_op": 2461003.2, "p75_ns_per_op": 2611945.68, "ops_per_second": 402.17, "samples_ns_per_op": [ 2710527.64, 2839077.18, 2463233.71, 2486535.93, 2450056.07, 2458772.69, 2513363.71 ], "extra": { "output_bytes": 6369 } } } }, "hash-throughput": { "slug": "hash-throughput", "iterations_per_sample": 110, "rounds": 7, "winner": "SHA-256", "slowest": "SHA-512", "spread_percent": 375.06, "variants": { "SHA-256": { "median_ns_per_op": 75545.19, "p25_ns_per_op": 75391.82, "p75_ns_per_op": 75926.82, "ops_per_second": 13237.11, "samples_ns_per_op": [ 76179.3, 75545.19, 75177.42, 75674.35, 75490.45, 76296.71, 75293.18 ], "extra": [] }, "SHA3-256": { "median_ns_per_op": 315705.03, "p25_ns_per_op": 313688.25, "p75_ns_per_op": 316226.88, "ops_per_second": 3167.51, "samples_ns_per_op": [ 313199.78, 316225.11, 318634.8, 315705.03, 307557.36, 314176.71, 316228.65 ], "extra": [] }, "SHA-512": { "median_ns_per_op": 358885.88, "p25_ns_per_op": 354277.36, "p75_ns_per_op": 360516.44, "ops_per_second": 2786.4, "samples_ns_per_op": [ 358885.88, 359041.99, 349069.8, 361990.89, 362268.24, 355806.28, 352748.45 ], "extra": [] } } }, "string-assembly": { "slug": "string-assembly", "iterations_per_sample": 150, "rounds": 7, "winner": "Incremental concatenation", "slowest": "Array plus implode", "spread_percent": 2.28, "variants": { "Incremental concatenation": { "median_ns_per_op": 46591.32, "p25_ns_per_op": 46226.81, "p75_ns_per_op": 49748.9, "ops_per_second": 21463.23, "samples_ns_per_op": [ 46191.91, 46591.32, 46050.86, 46261.71, 49037.79, 50460, 50554.91 ], "extra": [] }, "Array plus implode": { "median_ns_per_op": 47655.13, "p25_ns_per_op": 44826.78, "p75_ns_per_op": 48340.15, "ops_per_second": 20984.1, "samples_ns_per_op": [ 48410.29, 44713.14, 44940.42, 44611.08, 47655.13, 48270.02, 54353.45 ], "extra": [] } } }, "membership-lookups": { "slug": "membership-lookups", "iterations_per_sample": 35, "rounds": 7, "winner": "Associative map lookup", "slowest": "Linear array_search", "spread_percent": 43350.46, "variants": { "Associative map lookup": { "median_ns_per_op": 38364.94, "p25_ns_per_op": 38221.8, "p75_ns_per_op": 39246.44, "ops_per_second": 26065.46, "samples_ns_per_op": [ 52423.31, 38364.94, 38086.97, 37689.37, 38356.63, 38978.37, 39514.51 ], "extra": [] }, "Linear array_search": { "median_ns_per_op": 16669744.66, "p25_ns_per_op": 14044121.07, "p75_ns_per_op": 16917337.34, "ops_per_second": 59.99, "samples_ns_per_op": [ 13976812.17, 13828272.29, 16861099.57, 16973575.11, 16669744.66, 14111429.97, 17175381.43 ], "extra": [] } } }, "deduplication-strategies": { "slug": "deduplication-strategies", "iterations_per_sample": 35, "rounds": 7, "winner": "array_unique", "slowest": "Keyed set", "spread_percent": 139.92, "variants": { "array_unique": { "median_ns_per_op": 48937.66, "p25_ns_per_op": 48825.59, "p75_ns_per_op": 51770.81, "ops_per_second": 20434.16, "samples_ns_per_op": [ 48937.66, 50472.23, 53069.4, 48648.54, 48836.31, 48814.86, 63079.91 ], "extra": [] }, "Keyed set": { "median_ns_per_op": 117410.29, "p25_ns_per_op": 116719.86, "p75_ns_per_op": 118568.74, "ops_per_second": 8517.14, "samples_ns_per_op": [ 118270.17, 116543.23, 117410.29, 116896.49, 118867.31, 124850.29, 115549.4 ], "extra": [] } } }, "date-parsing": { "slug": "date-parsing", "iterations_per_sample": 20, "rounds": 7, "winner": "strtotime", "slowest": "DateTimeImmutable", "spread_percent": 15.69, "variants": { "strtotime": { "median_ns_per_op": 880153.55, "p25_ns_per_op": 873586.45, "p75_ns_per_op": 884418.28, "ops_per_second": 1136.17, "samples_ns_per_op": [ 884547.25, 880153.55, 875973.7, 898564.1, 884289.3, 871199.2, 870301.5 ], "extra": [] }, "DateTimeImmutable": { "median_ns_per_op": 1018260.55, "p25_ns_per_op": 1015105.35, "p75_ns_per_op": 1047175.88, "ops_per_second": 982.07, "samples_ns_per_op": [ 1018260.55, 1069752.8, 1007728.75, 1052809, 1016579.4, 1013631.3, 1041542.75 ], "extra": [] } } }, "serialization-roundtrip": { "slug": "serialization-roundtrip", "iterations_per_sample": 55, "rounds": 7, "winner": "PHP serialize round trip", "slowest": "JSON round trip", "spread_percent": 76.58, "variants": { "PHP serialize round trip": { "median_ns_per_op": 425054.38, "p25_ns_per_op": 420631.06, "p75_ns_per_op": 429561.47, "ops_per_second": 2352.64, "samples_ns_per_op": [ 420989.09, 528907.67, 428925.09, 420273.04, 430197.85, 413977.75, 425054.38 ], "extra": { "output_bytes": 106020 } }, "JSON round trip": { "median_ns_per_op": 750561, "p25_ns_per_op": 743848.93, "p75_ns_per_op": 861242.12, "ops_per_second": 1332.34, "samples_ns_per_op": [ 752757.49, 1069925.93, 750561, 969726.75, 745351.02, 741937.18, 742346.84 ], "extra": { "output_bytes": 67457 } } } }, "query-string-generation": { "slug": "query-string-generation", "iterations_per_sample": 600, "rounds": 7, "winner": "RFC 3986 encoding", "slowest": "RFC 1738 default", "spread_percent": 2.78, "variants": { "RFC 3986 encoding": { "median_ns_per_op": 1045.78, "p25_ns_per_op": 1041.18, "p75_ns_per_op": 1111.98, "ops_per_second": 956222.54, "samples_ns_per_op": [ 1038.95, 1043.41, 1030.89, 1232.2, 1053.01, 1045.78, 1170.95 ], "extra": { "output_bytes": 240 } }, "RFC 1738 default": { "median_ns_per_op": 1074.84, "p25_ns_per_op": 1045.81, "p75_ns_per_op": 1090.21, "ops_per_second": 930373.92, "samples_ns_per_op": [ 1079.76, 1067.6, 1021.67, 1124.08, 1100.67, 1024.02, 1074.84 ], "extra": { "output_bytes": 238 } } } }, "html-escaping": { "slug": "html-escaping", "iterations_per_sample": 450, "rounds": 7, "winner": "ENT_NOQUOTES + substitute", "slowest": "ENT_QUOTES + substitute", "spread_percent": 3.68, "variants": { "ENT_NOQUOTES + substitute": { "median_ns_per_op": 23983.1, "p25_ns_per_op": 23483.84, "p75_ns_per_op": 24222.77, "ops_per_second": 41696.02, "samples_ns_per_op": [ 25560.76, 23490.18, 23477.51, 23175, 23983.1, 24184.63, 24260.92 ], "extra": { "output_bytes": 8240 } }, "ENT_QUOTES + substitute": { "median_ns_per_op": 24865.72, "p25_ns_per_op": 24681.57, "p75_ns_per_op": 24922.52, "ops_per_second": 40216.02, "samples_ns_per_op": [ 27104.17, 24924.74, 24075.99, 24534.67, 24920.31, 24828.47, 24865.72 ], "extra": { "output_bytes": 9840 } } } }, "file-read-strategy": { "slug": "file-read-strategy", "iterations_per_sample": 18, "rounds": 7, "winner": "64 KiB chunked fread", "slowest": "file_get_contents", "spread_percent": 239.89, "variants": { "64 KiB chunked fread": { "median_ns_per_op": 206067.22, "p25_ns_per_op": 203628.36, "p75_ns_per_op": 209555.61, "ops_per_second": 4852.79, "samples_ns_per_op": [ 211739.44, 215255.5, 203112.11, 206067.22, 204144.61, 195052.56, 207371.78 ], "extra": { "input_bytes": 2097152 } }, "file_get_contents": { "median_ns_per_op": 700396.33, "p25_ns_per_op": 666884.53, "p75_ns_per_op": 733855.67, "ops_per_second": 1427.76, "samples_ns_per_op": [ 700396.33, 713454.28, 756617.06, 660037.22, 673731.83, 754257.06, 641217.44 ], "extra": { "input_bytes": 2097152 } } } }, "file-integrity-hashing": { "slug": "file-integrity-hashing", "iterations_per_sample": 14, "rounds": 7, "winner": "hash_file SHA-256", "slowest": "Read then hash SHA-256", "spread_percent": 30.62, "variants": { "hash_file SHA-256": { "median_ns_per_op": 1749501.07, "p25_ns_per_op": 1726130.75, "p75_ns_per_op": 1766130.57, "ops_per_second": 571.59, "samples_ns_per_op": [ 1749501.07, 1774581.07, 1745121.36, 1834807.79, 1757680.07, 1707140.14, 1702787.64 ], "extra": [] }, "Read then hash SHA-256": { "median_ns_per_op": 2285194.64, "p25_ns_per_op": 2275567.57, "p75_ns_per_op": 2357133.43, "ops_per_second": 437.6, "samples_ns_per_op": [ 2285194.64, 2327846.29, 2386420.57, 2597227.29, 2280928.71, 2270206.43, 2244755.93 ], "extra": [] } } }, "numeric-aggregation": { "slug": "numeric-aggregation", "iterations_per_sample": 180, "rounds": 7, "winner": "array_sum", "slowest": "foreach accumulator", "spread_percent": 356.25, "variants": { "array_sum": { "median_ns_per_op": 9471.46, "p25_ns_per_op": 9458.19, "p75_ns_per_op": 9899.55, "ops_per_second": 105580.39, "samples_ns_per_op": [ 9471.46, 9456.16, 9434.33, 9749.21, 9460.22, 10049.88, 10206.23 ], "extra": [] }, "foreach accumulator": { "median_ns_per_op": 43213.3, "p25_ns_per_op": 41559.52, "p75_ns_per_op": 53404.72, "ops_per_second": 23141.02, "samples_ns_per_op": [ 53594.58, 55233.49, 53214.87, 40591.59, 41166.89, 43213.3, 41952.15 ], "extra": [] } } }, "atomic-file-publishing": { "slug": "atomic-file-publishing", "iterations_per_sample": 35, "rounds": 7, "winner": "Temporary file + rename", "slowest": "Direct overwrite", "spread_percent": 43.63, "variants": { "Temporary file + rename": { "median_ns_per_op": 168694.94, "p25_ns_per_op": 155252.24, "p75_ns_per_op": 177618.13, "ops_per_second": 5927.86, "samples_ns_per_op": [ 158077.83, 152426.66, 178325.63, 176910.63, 181928.09, 140683.17, 168694.94 ], "extra": [] }, "Direct overwrite": { "median_ns_per_op": 242304.66, "p25_ns_per_op": 232811.11, "p75_ns_per_op": 248449.07, "ops_per_second": 4127.04, "samples_ns_per_op": [ 245128.26, 242304.66, 234313.09, 265150.43, 251769.89, 207609.46, 231309.14 ], "extra": [] } } }, "random-token-encoding": { "slug": "random-token-encoding", "iterations_per_sample": 1100, "rounds": 7, "winner": "Hex token", "slowest": "Base64url token", "spread_percent": 18.43, "variants": { "Hex token": { "median_ns_per_op": 539.95, "p25_ns_per_op": 523.74, "p75_ns_per_op": 564.34, "ops_per_second": 1852017.1, "samples_ns_per_op": [ 570.87, 557.8, 539.95, 530.12, 517.36, 505.67, 614.22 ], "extra": { "output_bytes": 48 } }, "Base64url token": { "median_ns_per_op": 639.45, "p25_ns_per_op": 635.92, "p75_ns_per_op": 667.93, "ops_per_second": 1563852.82, "samples_ns_per_op": [ 682.21, 739.23, 632.4, 628.45, 639.45, 639.45, 653.65 ], "extra": { "output_bytes": 32 } } } }, "csv-vs-jsonl-parsing": { "slug": "csv-vs-jsonl-parsing", "iterations_per_sample": 40, "rounds": 7, "winner": "JSON Lines rows", "slowest": "CSV rows", "spread_percent": 152.06, "variants": { "JSON Lines rows": { "median_ns_per_op": 226005.6, "p25_ns_per_op": 225217.49, "p75_ns_per_op": 228155.26, "ops_per_second": 4424.67, "samples_ns_per_op": [ 226048.18, 226005.6, 274274.3, 230262.35, 225346.63, 225088.35, 219953.98 ], "extra": { "input_bytes": 21802 } }, "CSV rows": { "median_ns_per_op": 569660.48, "p25_ns_per_op": 568262.63, "p75_ns_per_op": 592052.69, "ops_per_second": 1755.43, "samples_ns_per_op": [ 596483.38, 568312.23, 568213.03, 569660.48, 567116.43, 587622, 605817.15 ], "extra": { "input_bytes": 6092 } } } } } }